top of page

NCUA’s Dead Links Aren’t Redactions

1 day ago
3 min read


At NCUA’s budget briefing, a commenter from the GoWest Credit Union Association raised something that sounds minor: dead links on the agency’s website. NCUA’s site is valuable to their members, he said, but the dead links are a problem. Chairman John Crews answered directly. Let us know where they are, and we’ll get them fixed. The agency wants to be transparent.

I’m hearing good things about Chairman Crews from my contacts at NCUA, and his demeanor at the briefing was excellent. I took the offer at face value. I also think it reaches further than he may have had in mind.


The merger report that didn’t come out


The day after the briefing, Credit Union Times contacted me. NCUA hasn’t published its quarterly merger and insurance information report for June, with September call report data close behind, and the agency told the paper it is rethinking whether to publish it.

That report shows how many new members there are, how many credit unions go away, why they merged, and who they merged into. It shows charter conversions in both directions, and on the rare occasion a credit union leaves federal insurance for private insurance, it shows that they exited the system. Trade associations use it. I think members of Congress might. It’s great for research.

When I was Executive Director, the board regularly found out what staff was considering before staff had briefed them, usually because a credit union raised it with a board member. Then the board would reverse it. That may happen here. There’s also a simpler lever. If NCUA gets FOIA’d for something three times, it essentially has to put it on the website.


What the NSPM is for


The National Supervision Policy Manual started around 2012 or 2013, while I was finishing as a regional director or starting as Executive Director. It exists for consistency. Regions had been layering their own exam policies on top of national ones, so the western region would do something the southern and eastern regions didn’t. NCUA created a committee to own the manual and ended layering. A region that wants a policy brings it to the committee, and it gets done nationally.

NCUA now says it publishes the manual to help credit unions understand its internal policies, shape expectations, and reduce misunderstandings during exams, while not establishing separate requirements. That’s the guidance versus regulation question, and I get that. But the other banking agencies are more transparent than NCUA. That just is the reality, because of the dead links.


Two links that go nowhere


On page 400 of the 443-page manual, examiners are told to complete the applicable tabs of the subordinated debt questionnaire. Click the link and you get “file not found.” The file sits on NCUA’s internal system, available to employees logged in with an ID card. The OCC provides a similar checklist for banks. NCUA, in proposed regulations in the past, specifically referred to putting this guidance in the NSPM. It’s referenced there, and then it’s blocked.

Whether that’s a top-ten problem for the agency, I’ll leave aside. It’s a problem if you get denied for sub debt and NCUA is hiding how it says it will evaluate you, on safety and soundness, which is a nebulous term. In my opinion, it protects staff’s decisions. It also cuts against the reason NCUA gives for publishing the manual.

The second example is the enforcement manual, NCUA Instruction 4820. The link routes to an NCUA employee sign-in. I obtained a redacted copy through FOIA, and NCUA has a redacted version with, I don’t know, seventy percent of it public. The public link gives you none of it. Steve Farrar, now on my team, wrote that manual when we were both at NCUA.


Missing is not the same as redacted


An agency can redact things that would be problematic if released. But when a whole document is missing, nobody can argue that every word of it should be redacted. More likely the link wasn’t properly reviewed, or went dead for a reason — probably lack of resources, probably moving too fast. A document with nothing public isn’t a redaction. In my opinion, it’s an error.

I believe that if credit unions point these out to the chairman’s office, staff will be held to task. I’m considering walking the entire manual and turning what I find into a comment letter to the chairman. If that would be useful to you, let me know.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page