In 1980, Federal Credit Unions Couldn’t Charge More Than 12%. Then Rates Went Past It.

By Mark Treichel | Credit Union History
Every 18 months, the NCUA Board votes on the federal credit union loan rate ceiling. It is one of the more routine items on the agenda now. But the system behind that vote was built in a crisis, and NCUA’s 1980 annual report tells the story in the agency’s own words.
From “Federal Credit Unions in 1980,” NCUA Annual Report 1980 (published June 1981).
One percent a month
Going into 1980, a federal credit union could charge no more than one percent a month on a loan — 12% a year, including all service charges. That ceiling had been workable for decades. Then inflation and interest rates went to levels the country had not seen.
The report describes what happened as other rates rose to the ceiling and past it:
“Since Federal credit unions were restricted by the maximum interest rate ceiling, as other rates rose close to or above the ceiling they could not efficiently make loans to members. Consequently, despite member demand for loans, Federal credit unions were forced to curtail lending to avoid incurring operating losses.”
Members wanted to borrow. Credit unions had the money. But at 12%, a loan cost more to make than it earned. So the money went into short-term investments instead.
Then Washington made it harder
On March 14, 1980, the President invoked the Credit Control Act of 1969 and the Federal Reserve launched its Credit Restraint Program. Any lender that grew its unsecured consumer credit — credit unions included — had to park 15% of the increase with the Fed in a deposit that earned nothing. Secured loans such as autos and home improvement were exempt.
Loan demand dropped further. The report says loans outstanding “declined considerably for the first six months of the year.”
Congress changes the system
Relief came two weeks later. The Depository Institutions Deregulation and Monetary Control Act, signed March 31, 1980, raised the ceiling to 15%. And for the first time, it let the NCUA Board raise the ceiling above 15% for up to 18 months at a time, under certain conditions.
NCUA had asked for it. Earlier that year, Board Member Harold Black had introduced NCUA’s proposal to exceed the 12% ceiling in testimony before a House subcommittee.
It didn’t take long to use the new power. The Credit Restraint Program was suspended after midyear, and lending began to recover in the fall. Then rates spiked again. In the report’s words, that “caused the NCUA Board to raise the loan rate ceiling to 21% so the credit unions could remain competitive and at the same time, help relieve earnings pressures.”
The cost
Federal credit union loans outstanding fell 7.7% in 1980. Delinquency rose to its highest level in years: 3.3% of loan dollars were two months or more past due at year-end, up from 2.7%. The report linked it to heavy layoffs in durable goods and manufacturing, “since many credit unions are affiliated with these and other affected industries.” At the smallest credit unions, those under $50,000 in assets, 12.3% of loan dollars were delinquent.
The system we still use
The structure Congress built in 1980 is the one in place today. The statute sets 15%. The NCUA Board can raise it, 18 months at a time. Every time that vote comes up, this is the history behind it — a year when a fixed ceiling, a credit control program and a recession all hit credit unions at once.



Comments