How Bad Is A CAMEL Code 4?

Understanding CAMEL Code 4 Ratings for Credit Unions: Insights from Industry Experts

In the latest episode of "With Flying Colors," host Mark Treichel sits down with former NCUA veterans Steve Farrar and Todd Miller to unpack the complexities of CAMEL Code 4 ratings for credit unions. This insightful discussion sheds light on what these ratings mean, their implications, and how credit unions can navigate this challenging terrain.

What is a CAMEL Code 4 Rating?

A CAMEL Code 4 rating is a serious matter in the credit union world. According to our experts, it indicates that a credit union is exhibiting unsafe and unsound practices or conditions. The NCUA considers the risk management practices of these institutions to be unacceptable relative to their size and complexity. Moreover, there may be concerns about whether management is willing and able to correct these severe problems.

Implications of a Code 4 Rating

Receiving a Code 4 rating triggers a cascade of consequences:

1. Administrative Action: The credit union will typically face some form of administrative action, most commonly an unpublished Letter of Understanding and Agreement (LUA).

2. Increased Examinations: Examiners will visit every 120 days, meaning the credit union can expect 6-12 weeks of examiner presence annually.

3. Federal Reserve Implications: The credit union may lose access to Federal Reserve daylight overdrafts and face increased scrutiny on borrowing agreements.

4. Special Actions Assignment: Larger credit unions might be assigned to NCUA's Division of Special Actions, which can be both challenging and beneficial due to the experienced staff handling these cases.

5. Financial Institution Relationships: The Federal Home Loan Bank will eventually be notified, potentially affecting borrowing terms. Secondary market relationships, particularly with entities like Fannie Mae, may also be impacted.

Board and Management Responsibilities

A Code 4 rating places increased pressure on both the board and management:

- The board is expected to hold management more accountable and closely monitor progress on Document of Resolution (DOR) items and administrative actions.

- Management must keep the board well-informed about efforts to resolve issues.

- There's an expectation that the board will authorize necessary resources to address problems, even if it means increased expenses in the short term.

Financial Implications

The financial repercussions of a Code 4 rating can be far-reaching:

- For larger credit unions, it may affect the NCUSIF equity ratio.

- Lenders may impose stricter collateral requirements.

- Issues may arise with mortgage sales on the secondary market, potentially leading to the loss of servicing rights or requirements for additional collateral.

Regulatory Oversight

Under Code 4, regulatory oversight intensifies:

- NCUA approval is required for changes in senior management and board members.

- Document of Resolution (DOR) requirements become more detailed and voluminous.

- The credit union is officially classified as a "troubled credit union" under section 701.14 of NCUA regulations.

The Road to Recovery

While a Code 4 rating presents significant challenges, it's not a death sentence for a credit union. Our experts emphasize that with the right approach, many institutions can navigate this difficult period and emerge stronger. The key lies in transparent communication with regulators, swift action to address identified issues, and a commitment to improving risk management practices.

Conclusion

A CAMEL Code 4 rating represents a critical juncture for any credit union. It demands immediate attention, decisive action, and a willingness to work closely with regulators. By understanding the implications and requirements associated with this rating, credit union leaders can better position their institutions to address challenges and chart a path toward recovery.

Remember, while the journey may be tough, many credit unions have successfully navigated Code 4 ratings and returned to sound financial footing. With the right strategy and execution, your institution can too.

For more insights on navigating regulatory challenges and achieving success with NCUA, tune in to the "With Flying Colors" podcast, available on all major podcast platforms.

Reach out to learn how we assist our clients with NCUA so they save time and Money.